• Login
  • Join
  • Access Problems
  • Status
GRL Landlord Association
  • RH (Wales) Act
  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Subscribers
  • Services/Discounts
  • Forms
  • Recent
  • Contact
  • Find Answers
    • England Guidance
    • Wales Guidance
    • Housing Changes Timeline (E/W)
    • Admin/Tech Support
    • Search Website
    • Weekly Digest (Subscribe)
  • Ask a Question
    • Ask Question
    • View Questions
    • Your Q & A Activity (from Sept 2020)
Select Page

HMRC Loses CGT Tax Relief on Home Sale Case

by guildy | 22 Sep 2017 | Investing in a Property (England), Investing in a Property (Wales), News, Tax (England), Tax (Wales)

HMRC Loses CGT Tax Relief on Home Sale Case

The constant battle between property owners and HMRC over how long someone must live in a home to benefit from principal residence relief has been argued in front of a judge again.

The tussle between property people and HMRC is based on main residence tax relief.

Property owners – especially developers and landlords want to make the time as short as possible so they pay less capital gains tax on the sale of a home.

HMRC refuses to define the period so home owners have no yard stick.

As a result, cases are continually going before the courts as the tax saving – or prized for HMRC – can be significant.

The latest case was Stephen Bailey v HMRC.

Mr Bailey was accused of failing to pay £27,000 capital gains tax and penalties relating to a home he sold in Farnham, Surrey, in 2010.

The plan was to make the house a family home as he and his wife and children lived in separate properties.

Mr Bailey lived in the house for two short periods of eight to 10 weeks or so over two years.

HMRC argued he did not live in the property as his main home, so no tax relief was due on the sale.

The First Tier Tribunal disagreed and granted Mr Bailey main residence relief for the entire time he owned the home.

“I found Mr Bailey a straightforward witness and his evidence credible,” said the judge, Marilyn McKeever.

“I am satisfied that one each occasion when Mr Bailey moved into Richmond, he intended that his residence would be on a permanent basis and that the property would be his home.”

The residence test was set in Goodwin v Curtis (1998), which decided the quality of occupation rather than the length of time someone lived in a home was which counted the most. The taxpayer lost the case based on just 35 days of occupation.

Coronavirus Guidance

View now ...

Discounted landlords buildings insurance

Landlords Building Insurance

Guild subscribers can get preferential rates for landlords buildings insurance especially designed for landlords

Read more ...

Tenant Referencing Service

Tenant Referencing

Tenant Referencing Service

Read more ...

Recent Articles

  • Sub-occupation contracts (Subletting) (Wales) 19/05/2022
  • Exclusion of Contract-Holder From Dwelling for Specified Periods 18/05/2022
  • Landlord’s Consent Under Occupation Contract (Wales) 17/05/2022
  • Fire Safety Act 2021 17/05/2022
  • Service of Documents (Occupation Contracts) (Wales) 16/05/2022

Navigation

  • RH (Wales) Act
  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Subscribers
  • Services/Discounts
  • Forms
  • Recent
  • Contact
  • Find Answers
    • England Guidance
    • Wales Guidance
    • Housing Changes Timeline (E/W)
    • Admin/Tech Support
    • Search Website
    • Weekly Digest (Subscribe)
  • Ask a Question
    • Ask Question
    • View Questions
    • Your Q & A Activity (from Sept 2020)

Navigation

  • RH (Wales) Act
  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Subscribers
  • Services/Discounts
  • Forms
  • Recent
  • Contact
  • Find Answers
    • England Guidance
    • Wales Guidance
    • Housing Changes Timeline (E/W)
    • Admin/Tech Support
    • Search Website
    • Weekly Digest (Subscribe)
  • Ask a Question
    • Ask Question
    • View Questions
    • Your Q & A Activity (from Sept 2020)

Subscribers

  • Login
  • Join
  • Access Problems
  • Status

Please login

Please login to see your active subscriptions and account links.

Terms, About Us and Status

General terms and conditions

Website terms

Privacy policy

About Us

Status

(c) Guild of Residential Landlords

Recent Articles

  • Sub-occupation contracts (Subletting) (Wales) 19/05/2022
  • Exclusion of Contract-Holder From Dwelling for Specified Periods 18/05/2022
  • Landlord’s Consent Under Occupation Contract (Wales) 17/05/2022
  • Fire Safety Act 2021 17/05/2022
  • Service of Documents (Occupation Contracts) (Wales) 16/05/2022
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • RSS