• Login
  • Join
  • Access Problems
  • Status
GRL Landlord Association
  • RH (Wales) Act
  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Subscribers
  • Services/Discounts
  • Forms
  • Recent
  • Contact
  • Find Answers
    • England Guidance
    • Wales Guidance
    • Housing Changes Timeline (E/W)
    • Admin/Tech Support
    • Search Website
    • Weekly Digest (Subscribe)
  • Ask a Question
    • Ask Question
    • View Questions
    • Your Q & A Activity (from Sept 2020)
Select Page

Law Banning Benefit Tenants Remains Unclear for Landlords

by guildy | 2 Mar 2018 | Housing Benefit and Universal Credit (England), Housing Benefit and Universal Credit (Wales), News, Unlawful Discrimination (England), Unlawful Discrimination (Wales) | 1 comment

Law banning benefit tenants remains unclear for landlords

Landlords and letting agents may still be able turn away renters on benefits despite a single mum winning an out of court settlement after claiming an agent who did so breached equality legislation.

Letting agent Nicholas George paid the mum, Rosie Keogh, a £2,000 settlement before judgment after she issued a claim backed by housing charity Shelter at county court.

She argued that he had breached equality laws by turning down her application to rent a home in King’s Heath, Birmingham, after discovering some of the rent would be paid by housing benefit.

The papers before the court claimed landlords and letting agents refusing applications from benefit tenants indirectly discriminated against women as single women are proportionately more likely to claim housing benefit than single men according to official figures.

Reporting the case, the BBC pointed out thousands of landlords and letting agents who operate a ‘no tenants on benefits’ policy could be flouting equality laws.

“While an interesting development, this is not a precedent,” said solicitor Giles Peaker, a partner in housing law firm Anthony Gold Solicitors.

“While claims of indirect discrimination in such a blanket ban may be well founded and are clearly arguable, there remains the possibility of a defence under Section 19(2)(d) Equality Act 2010, that the practice is ‘a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim’. Unless or until that defence is tested in court, the issue will remain unclear.

“That said, this is a clear demonstration that something that a number of people have been discussing as a hypothetical possibility for some time is indeed a viable potential claim. And it is a reminder to landlords and agents that any simple ‘blanket letting policy’ actually needs to be considered carefully.”

Shelter asked 1,137 private landlords last year if they banned letting to benefit claimants.

The response was 43% said yes and another 18% preferred not to let to them

1 Comment

  1. sam bam
    sam bam on 05/03/2018 at 12:10 pm

    In that case the government need to legislate against the insurance companies as well, as most of them won’t insure landlords for buildings insurance if they have a ‘DSS’ tenant.

Coronavirus Guidance

View now ...

Discounted landlords buildings insurance

Landlords Building Insurance

Guild subscribers can get preferential rates for landlords buildings insurance especially designed for landlords

Read more ...

Tenant Referencing Service

Tenant Referencing

Tenant Referencing Service

Read more ...

Recent Articles

  • Is Your Home Earning More Than You? 24/06/2022
  • Are You an Unwitting Non-Resident Landlord? 23/06/2022
  • Renting Homes Amending Regulations (Wales) 23/06/2022
  • No Gas Safety Record Before Occupation and Section 21 22/06/2022
  • Renters’ Reform Bill – White Paper 21/06/2022

Navigation

  • RH (Wales) Act
  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Subscribers
  • Services/Discounts
  • Forms
  • Recent
  • Contact
  • Find Answers
    • England Guidance
    • Wales Guidance
    • Housing Changes Timeline (E/W)
    • Admin/Tech Support
    • Search Website
    • Weekly Digest (Subscribe)
  • Ask a Question
    • Ask Question
    • View Questions
    • Your Q & A Activity (from Sept 2020)

Navigation

  • RH (Wales) Act
  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Subscribers
  • Services/Discounts
  • Forms
  • Recent
  • Contact
  • Find Answers
    • England Guidance
    • Wales Guidance
    • Housing Changes Timeline (E/W)
    • Admin/Tech Support
    • Search Website
    • Weekly Digest (Subscribe)
  • Ask a Question
    • Ask Question
    • View Questions
    • Your Q & A Activity (from Sept 2020)

Subscribers

  • Login
  • Join
  • Access Problems
  • Status

Please login

Please login to see your active subscriptions and account links.

Terms, About Us and Status

General terms and conditions

Website terms

Privacy policy

About Us

Status

(c) Guild of Residential Landlords

Recent Articles

  • Is Your Home Earning More Than You? 24/06/2022
  • Are You an Unwitting Non-Resident Landlord? 23/06/2022
  • Renting Homes Amending Regulations (Wales) 23/06/2022
  • No Gas Safety Record Before Occupation and Section 21 22/06/2022
  • Renters’ Reform Bill – White Paper 21/06/2022
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • RSS